Does the Equality Act 2010 ensure equality for individuals with Asperger syndrome in the legal arena?: A survey of recent UK case law

Russell Foster

Abstract


The recent history of AS has been perhaps the most controversial since the first publication relating to the syndrome in 1944, especially regarding its nosology. For example, the latest (5th) version of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM-V) published in May, 2013 does not include Asperger syndrome (AS) and instead refers to AS as an ‘autistic spectrum disorder’. This change is controversial, and indeed, supports the suggestion that the research presented in this article is timely, given the potential for AS (as defined prior to DSM-V) to disappear from current clinical practice and cease to be recognised in law. In this article I investigate whether the Equality Act 2010 ensures equality for individuals with AS in the legal arena. My investigation involved identifying individual cases using two commonly used legal search engines, Westlaw and LexisNexis. Following the identification of specific cases, these were then analysed for relevance using any available case analyses and official transcripts. The findings presented in this article suggest that the Law may well still be potentially discriminating and not ensuring equality for individuals with AS, despite the introduction of the Equality Act 2010.


Keywords


Asperger syndrome; autism; Equality Act 2010

References


Adamou M, ‘Hidden impairments, the Equality Act and occupational physicians’ 61(7) Occupational Medicine 453

Allen D and others, ‘Offending behaviour in adults with Asperger Syndrome’ (2008) 38 Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 748

Anderlini L and others, ‘Statute Law or Case Law’ (2008) accessed 18 January 2014

Anderson D and others, ‘Mental health service discrimination against older people’ (2013) 37(3) The Psychiatrist 98

Archer N and Hurley EA, ‘A Justice System Failing the Autistic Community’ (2013) 4(12) Journal of Intellectual Disabilities and Offending Behaviour 53

Arnell P and Reid A, ‘Hackers beware: the cautionary story of Gary McKinnon’ (2009) 18(1) Information and Communications Technology Law 1

Arnold G, ‘UK-US extradition: the case of Gary McKinnon’ (2012) 67 Student Law Review 14

Asperger H, ‘Die Autistischen Pychopathen im Kindesalder’ (1944) 177 Archiv für Psychkiatrie und Nervenkrankheiten 76

Beardon L, ‘Asperger Syndrome and Perceived Offending Conduct: A Qualitative Study’ (PhD Thesis, Sheffield Hallam University 2008)

Bernard C, ‘Achieving age equality in health and social care’ (2013) 17 (1) Working with Older People 19

Brewin BJ and others, ‘Parental perspectives of the quality of life in school environments for children with Asperger Syndrome’ (2008) 23 ‘Focus on Autism and Other Developmental Disabilities’ 242

Browning A and Caulfield L, ‘The prevalence and treatment of people with Asperger’s Syndrome in the criminal justice system’ (2011) 11(2) Criminology and Criminal Justice 165

Butler RC and Gillis JM, ‘The impact of labels and behaviors on the stigmatization of adults with Asperger’s disorder’ (2011) 41(6) Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 741

Chaplin E and others, ‘Autism Spectrum Conditions and Offending: An Introduction to the special edition’ (2013) 4(1/2) Journal of Intellectual Disabilities and Offending Behaviour 1

Chown N, ‘Do you have any difficulties that I may not be aware of?' A study of autism awareness and understanding in the UK police service’ (2010) 12(2) International Journal of Police Science & Management 256

Cookson G, ‘Unintended Consequences: the cost of the Government’s Legal Aid Reforms’ (King’s College London 2011)

accessed 18 January 2014

Cooper JE, Pocket Guide to the ICD-10 Classification of Mental and Behavioural Disorders with Glossary and Diagnostic Criteria for Research (Churchill Livingstone 1999)

Corker E and others, ‘Experiences of discrimination among people using mental health services in England 2008-2011’ (2013) 202(s55) The British Journal of Psychiatry s58

Crawford NW and Buttery JP, ‘Adverse events following immunizations: fact and fiction’ (2013) 23(3) Paediatrics and Child Health 121

Debbaudt D, Autism, advocates, and law enforcement professionals. Recognising and reducing risk situations for people with Autism Spectrum Disorders (Jessica Kingsley 2002)

Department of Health, ‘Health Service Circular 2001/016. Valuing People: A New Strategy for Learning Difficulty for the 21st Century: Implementation Guidance’ (Department of Health, 31 August 2001)

Department of Health, ‘Implementing “Fulfilling and rewarding lives”. Statutory guidance for local authorities and NHS organisations to support implementation of the autism strategy’ (Department of Health 17 December 2010)

Department of Health, ‘Valuing People Now: a new three-year strategy for people with learning difficulties. Making it happen for everyone’ (Department of Health, 19 January 2009)

Dillenburger K, and others, ‘Awareness and knowledge of autism and autism interventions: A general population survey’ (2013) 7(12) Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders 1558

Ehlers S and Gillberg C, ‘The epidemiology of Asperger syndrome’ (1993) 34(8) Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 1327

Fitzgerald M, ‘Loss of autism in DSM-V’ (2012) 201 British Journal of Psychiatry 74

Fitzgerald M and Corvin A, ‘Diagnosis and differential diagnosis of Asperger syndrome’ (2001) 7 Advances in Psychiatric Treatment 310

Foster R, ‘What Theories of Asperger Syndrome Support or Undermine the Suggestion that Individuals with Asperger Syndrome are Likely to Break the Law?’ Unpublished Coursework, PostGraduate Certificate in Autism and Asperger Syndrome, Sheffield Hallam University (31 August 2013)

Freckleton I, ‘Asperger’s disorder and the criminal law’ (2011) 18 Journal of Law and Medicine 677

Freckleton I, ‘Autism Spectrum Disorder: Forensic Issues and Challenges for Mental Health Professionals and Courts’ (2013) 26(5) Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities 420

Godlee F and others, ‘Wakefield’s article linking MMR vaccine and autism was fraudulent’ (2011) British Medical Journal 342 1678

Hare DJ and others, A Preliminary Study of Individuals with Autistic Spectrum Disorders in Three Special Hospitals in England (National Autistic Society 1999)

Haskins BG and Arturo Silva J, ‘Asperger's Disorder and Criminal Behavior: Forensic-Psychiatric Considerations’ (2006) 34(3) Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and Law 374

Heiderken AD and others, ‘A survey of autism knowledge in a health care setting’ (2005) 35(3) Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 323

Hepple B, ‘The New Single Equality Act in Britain’ (2010) 5 The Equal Rights Review 11

Hippler K and others, ‘Brief report: No increase in Criminal Convictions in Hans Asperger’s Original Cohort’ (2010) 40 Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 774

HM Government, ‘Autism Act 2009 Explanatory Notes’

Huws JC and Jones RSP, ‘Missing voices: representations of autism in British newspapers, 1999–2008’ (2011) 39(2) British Journal of Learning Disabilities 98

Jones SC and Harwood V, ‘Representations of autism in Australian print media’ (2009) 24(1) Disability And Society 5

Katz N and Zemishlany Z, ‘Criminal Responsibility in Asperger Syndrome’ (2006) 43(3) Israeli Journal of Psychiatry Related Science 166

Kearns A, ‘Forensic services and people with learning disability: in the shadow of the Reed Report’ (2001) 12(1) Journal of Forensic Psychiatry 8

Kendler K, ‘An historic framework for psychiatric nosology’ (2009) 39(12) Psychological Medicine 1935

Knapp M and others, ‘Economic cost of autism in the UK’ (2009) 13(3) Autism 317

Knopf A, ‘Asperger’s diagnosis disappears, will treatment disappear too?’ [2013] Behavioral Healthcare

Langan M, ‘Parental voices and controversies in autism’ (2011) 26(2) Disability and Society 193

Lian WB and others, ‘General practitioners' knowledge on childhood developmental and behavioural disorders’ (2003) 44(8) Singapore Medical Journal 397

Lockwood G and others, ‘The Equality Act 2010 and mental health’ (2012) 200 British Journal of Psychiatry 182

Mattila ML and others, ‘An epidemiological and diagnostic study of Asperger syndrome according to four sets of diagnostic criteria’ (2007) 46(5) Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry 636

Micale MS, ‘On the “Disappearance” of Hysteria: A Study in the Clinical Deconstruction of a Diagnosis’ (1993) 84(3) Isis 496

Mouridson SE and others, ‘Pervasive developmental disorders and criminal behaviour: A case control study’ (2008) 52(2) International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology 196

National Autistic Society, ‘I Exist Campaign in England’ (National Autistic Society 9 May 2013)

Onyett S and Lester H, ‘Managing in Mental Health’ in Kieran Walshe and Judith Smith (eds), Healthcare Management (Open University Press 2006)

Paris J, Fads and Fallacies in Psychiatry (RCPsych Publications 2013)

Peay J, ‘Fitness to Plead and Core Competencies: Problems and Possibilities’ (London School of Economics Law, Society and Economy Working Papers 2012)

Phillips C, ‘The Equality Act 2010: Impact on mental health-related disability claims’ (2012) 109 Employment Law Bulletin 2

Poland GA,’MMR vaccine and autism: vaccine nihilism and postmodern science’ (2011) 86(9) Mayo Clinic Proceedings 869

Poland GA and Jacobson RM, ‘The age-old struggle against the antivaccinationists’ (2011) 364(2) New England Journal of Medicine 97

Porter J and others, ‘Recognising the needs of every disabled child: the development of tools for a disability census’ (2011) 38(3) British Journal of Special Education 120

Posner RA, ‘Statutory Interpretation—in the Classroom and in the Courtroom’ (1983) 50 Chicago Law Review 800

Przybylski BK. ‘The Legal Framework as a Factor Generating Social Inequality: The Case of the Criminal Justice System’ in Dieter Eissel, Ewa

Read J and others, ‘Disabled children and their families: a decade of policy change’ (2012) 26(3) Children & Society 223

Rokicka and Jeremy Leaman (eds), Welfare State at Risk (Springer International Publishing 2014)

Roy M and Balaratnasingam S, ‘Missed diagnosis of autism in an Australian Indigenous psychiatric population’ (2010) 18(6) Australasian Psychiatry 534

Royal College of Psychiatrists, ‘On Planning a Portfolio Career’ (Royal College of Psychiatrists 2008)

Schell BH and Melnychuk J, ‘Female and Male Hacker Conferences Attendees: Their Autism-Spectrum Quotient (AQ) Scores and Self-Reported Adulthood Experiences’ Corporate hacking and technology driven crime: Social dynamics and implications (Information Science Reference 2010) 144

Schwarz E and others, ‘Sex-specific serum biomarker patterns in adults with Asperger's syndrome’ (2010) 16(12) Molecular Psychiatry 1213

Scragg P and Shah A, ‘Prevalence of Asperger’s Syndrome in a secure hospital’ (1994) 165 British Journal of Psychiatry 679

Shah K, ‘What do medical students know about autism?’ (2001) 5(2) Autism 127

Sharma S and others, ‘Confusion and inconsistency in diagnosis of Asperger syndrome: a review of studies from 1981 to 2010’ (2011) 16(5) Autism 465

Shorter E and Marshall JC, A History of Psychiatry (Wiley 1997)

Siponmaa L and others, ‘Juvenile and young adult mentally disordered offenders: The role of child neuropsychiatric disorders’ (2001) 29 Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law 420

Sisk G, ‘The Quantitative Moment and the Qualitative Opportunity: Legal Studies of Judicial Decision Making (Book Review)’ (2008) 93 Cornell Law Review 8

Smith SA, ‘Comparative legal scholarship as ordinary legal scholarship’ (2102) 5(3) Journal of Comparative Law 331

Taylor RE, ‘Death of neurasthenia and its psychological reincarnation A study of neurasthenia at the National Hospital for the Relief and Cure of the Paralysed and Epileptic, Queen Square, London, 1870-1932’ (2001) 179(6) The British Journal of Psychiatry 550

Teagardin J and others, ‘Randomized trial of law enforcement training on autism spectrum disorders’ (2012) 6(3) Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders 1113

Thornicroft G, Shunned: Discrimination against people with mental illness (Oxford University Press 2006)

Tremper C and others, ‘Measuring Law for Evaluation Research’ (2010) 34(3) Evaluation Research 242

Underwood L and others, ‘Prisoners with neurodevelopmental disorders’ (2013) 4 Journal of Intellectual Disabilities and Offending Behaviour 17

United Nations Rule of Law, ‘Measuring Effectiveness’ (2013) (United Nations 2013)

Vanbergeijk EO and Shtayermman O, ‘Asperger's syndrome: An enigma for social work’ (2005) 12(1) Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment 23

Veale D, ‘The Department of Health and the Equality Act 2010’ (2012) 201 British Journal of Psychiatry 75

Walsh N and Hall I, ‘The Autism Strategy: implications for people with autism and for service development’ (2012) 6(3) Advances in Mental Health and Intellectual Disabilities 113

Weiss KJ, ‘Autism Spectrum Disorder and Criminal Justice: Square Peg in a Round Hole’ (2011) 32(3) American Journal of Forensic Psychiatry 3

Wilkinson LA, ‘The Gender Gap in Asperger Syndrome: Where are the Girls?’ (2008) 4(4) Teaching Exceptional Children Plus 3

Woodbury-Smith M and others, ‘High functioning autistic spectrum disorders, offending and other law-breaking from a community sample’ (2006) 17(1) Journal of Forensic Psychiatry and Psychology 108

Young S and others, ‘The effectiveness of police custody assessments in identifying suspects with intellectual disabilities and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder’ (2013) 11(1) BMC Medicine 248

Statutes and Statutory Instruments

Autism Act 2009

Criminal Justice Act 2003

Disability Discrimination Act 1995

Employment Equality (Age) Regulations 2006

Employment Equality (Religion or Belief) Regulations 2003

Employment Equality (Sexual Orientation) Regulations 2003

Equality Act 2006

Equality Act 2010

Equality Act (Sexual Orientation) Regulations 2007

Equal Pay Act 1970

Mental Capacity Act 2005

Mental Health Act 2007

Race Relations Act 1976

Sex Discrimination Act 1975

Cases

Goodwin v Patent Office [1999] I.C.R. 302

Hewett v Motorola Ltd [2004] I.R.L.R. 545

Parents of C v Stanbridge Earls School [2013] Eq. L.R. 304

P v Governing Body of A Primary School [2013] UKUT 154 (AAT)

Telchadder v Wickland (Holdings) Ltd [2012] EWCA Civ 635

R (on the application of Islam) v General Medical Council [2013] EWHC 3763

R. (on the application of T) v Secretary of State for Justice [2013] EWHC 1119 Admin

R. (on the application of W) v Aylesbury Crown Court [2013] EWHC 3228 (Admin)

R v Pritchard (1836) 7 C & P 303

Swan Housing Association Ltd v Gill [2013] EWCA Civ 1566

ZH v Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [2013] EWCA Civ 69


Full Text: HTML

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.