Deconstructing diagnosis: multi-disciplinary perspectives on a diagnostic tool

Damian Milton, Steven Kapp, Virginia Bovell, Sami Timimi, Ginny Russell

Abstract


Diagnostic assessment tools are widely used instruments in research and clinical practice to assess and evaluate autism symptoms for both children and adults. These tools typically involve observing the child or adult under assessment, and rating their behaviour for signs or so-called symptoms of autism.

In order to examine how autism diagnosis is constructed, how diagnostic tools are positioned, and how their trainings are delivered, we paid for four places on a training course for a diagnostic tool. We asked the attendees (the first four authors) to each produce a critical commentary about their impressions of the training and the diagnostic tool itself. Their commentaries are published here in full.  They have various disciplinary backgrounds: one is a social scientist, one an ethicist, one a psychiatrist, and one a developmental psychologist.

The commentaries are followed by a concluding section that summarises the themes, commonalities, and differences between their accounts of the training course. Authors differed as to whether the diagnostic tool is a useful and necessary endeavour. Nevertheless, all critiqued of the tool’s lack of transparency, recognizing context, emotion, and differences in interpretation and power imbalances as playing an unidentified role in the assessment process. Based on this project, we recommend that training for raters for such tools should be accessible to a wider group of people, and incorporate more explicit recognition of its own limitations and commercialisation.

Keywords


Autism, diagnosis, assessment, ADOS

References


Akhtar, Nameera, and Morton Ann Gernsbacher. 2008. On Privileging the Role of Gaze in Infant Social Cognition. Child Development Perspectives. 2(2): 59–65.

Anderson, Deborah K., Jessie W. Liang, and Catherine Lord. 2014. Predicting Young Adult Outcome among More and Less Cognitively Able Individuals with Autism Spectrum Disorders. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry. 55(5): 485–494.

Atkinson, Paul. 1995. Medical Talk and Medical Work: The Liturgy of the Clinic. 1 edition. London: Sage Publications UK..

Bird, Geoffrey, Jane Leighton, Clare Press, and Cecilia Heyes. 2007. Intact Automatic Imitation of Human and Robot Actions in Autism Spectrum Disorders. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London B: Biological Sciences. 274(1628): 3027–3031.

Brugha, T. S., S. McManus, J. Smith, et al. 2012. Validating Two Survey Methods for Identifying Cases of Autism Spectrum Disorder among Adults in the Community. Psychological Medicine. 42(3): 647–656.

Cage, Eilidh, Elizabeth Pellicano, Punit Shah, and Geoffrey Bird. 2013. Reputation Management: Evidence for Ability But Reduced Propensity in Autism. Autism Research. 6(5): 433–442.

Chapman, Robert. 2016. Autism Isn’t Just A Medical Diagnosis — It’s A Political Identity. The Establishment. https://theestablishment.co/autism-isnt-just-a-medical-diagnosis-it-s-a-political-identity-178137688bd5, accessed July 17, 2017.

Chapman, Robert. 2017. Autism and Intersectional Theory. Paper presented at the Autism and Society Seminar II: Autistic Wellbeing, UCL Institute of Education, London, March 1.

Chown, Nicholas. 2014. More on the Ontological Status of Autism and Double Empathy. Disability & Society. 29(10): 1672–1676.

Chown, Nicholas Paul. 2013. The Mismeasure of Autism: A Challenge to Orthodox Autism Theory. Autonomy, the Critical Journal of Interdisciplinary Autism Studies 1(2). http://www.larry-arnold.net/Autonomy/index.php/autonomy/article/view/AR5, accessed July 17, 2017.

Cottenceau, Hélène, Sylvie Roux, Romuald Blanc, et al. 2012. Quality of Life of Adolescents with Autism Spectrum Disorders: Comparison to Adolescents with Diabetes. European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry. 21(5): 289–296.

Dawson, Michelle. 2012. CRAE LectureInstitute of Education, London, March 1.

Dekker, Martijn. 2016. Cure versus Acceptance: A False Dichotomy? Paper presented at the Autism-Europe Conference, Edinburgh, September 16.

Docherty, Meagan, Paul Boxer, L. Rowell Huesmann, Maureen O’Brien, and Brad J. Bushman. 2016. Exploring Primary and Secondary Variants of Psychopathy in Adolescents in Detention and in the Community. Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology. 45(5): 564–578.

Doherty-Sneddon, Gwyneth, Deborah M. Riby, and Lisa Whittle. 2012. Gaze Aversion as a Cognitive Load Management Strategy in Autism Spectrum Disorder and Williams Syndrome. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry. 53(4): 420–430.

Dreaper, Jane. 2017. Autism Diagnoses “Could Be Reduced under NHS Plan.” BBC News, May 27. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-40058482, accessed July 17, 2017.

Edens, John F., Marcus T. Boccaccini, and Darryl W. Johnson. 2010. Inter-Rater Reliability of the PCL-R Total and Factor Scores among Psychopathic Sex Offenders: Are Personality Features More Prone to Disagreement than Behavioral Features? Behavioral Sciences & the Law. 28(1): 106–119.

Elsabbagh, Mayada, Evelyne Mercure, Kristelle Hudry, et al. 2012. Infant Neural Sensitivity to Dynamic Eye Gaze Is Associated with Later Emerging Autism. Current Biology. 22(4): 338–342.

Falck-Ytter, Terje. 2015. Gaze Performance during Face-to-Face Communication: A Live Eye Tracking Study of Typical Children and Children with Autism. Research in Autism Spectrum Disorders. 17: 78–85.

Fecteau, Shirley, Laurent Mottron, Claude Berthiaume, and Jacob A. Burack. 2003. Developmental Changes of Autistic Symptoms. Autism. 7(3): 255–268.

Feldman, Ruth, Ofer Golan, Yael Hirschler-Guttenberg, Sharon Ostfeld-Etzion, and Orna Zagoory-Sharon. 2014. Parent-Child Interaction and Oxytocin Production in Pre-Schoolers with Autism Spectrum Disorder. The British Journal of Psychiatry. 205(2): 107–112.

Fleming, Bernard, Elizabeth Hurley, and The Goth. 2016. Choosing Autism Interventions: A Research-Based Guide. United Kingdom: Pavilion Publishing and Media Ltd.

Foucault, Michel. 1973. The Birth of the Clinic. trans. A. Sheridan, London: Tavistock.

Fountain, Christine, Alix S. Winter, and Peter S. Bearman. 2012. Six Developmental Trajectories Characterize Children With Autism. Pediatrics. 129(5): e1112–e1120.

Fowler, Katherine A., Scott O. Lilienfeld, and Christopher J. Patrick. 2009. Detecting Psychopathy from Thin Slices of Behavior. Psychological Assessment 21(1): 68–78.

Gallagher, Shaun, and Somogy Varga. 2015. Conceptual Issues in Autism Spectrum Disorders. Current Opinion in Psychiatry. 28(2): 127–132.

Gernsbacher, Morton Ann, and Jennifer L. Frymiare. 2005. Does the Autistic Brain Lack Core Modules? The Journal of Developmental and Learning Disorders. 9: 3–16.

Gernsbacher, Morton Ann, Jennifer L. Stevenson, and Sebastian Dern. 2017. Specificity, Contexts, and Reference Groups Matter When Assessing Autistic Traits. PLOS ONE. 12(2): e0171931.

Gernsbacher, Morton Ann, Jennifer L. Stevenson, Suraiya Khandakar, and H. Hill Goldsmith. 2008. Why Does Joint Attention Look Atypical in Autism? Child Development Perspectives. 2(1): 38–45.

Gliga, T., E. J. H. Jones, R. Bedford, T. Charman, and M. H. Johnson. 2014. From Early Markers to Neuro-Developmental Mechanisms of Autism. Developmental Review. 34(3): 189–207.

Grandin, Temple. 2006. Thinking in Pictures, Expanded Edition: My Life with Autism. Vintage.

Grinker, Roy Richard, Nola Chambers, Nono Njongwe, et al. 2012. “Communities” in Community Engagement: Lessons Learned From Autism Research in South Korea and South Africa. Autism Research. 5(3): 201–210.

Hanley, Mary, Martin McPhillips, Gerry Mulhern, and Deborah M Riby. 2013. Spontaneous Attention to Faces in Asperger Syndrome Using Ecologically Valid Static Stimuli. Autism. 17(6): 754–761.

Happé, Francesca, and Angelica Ronald. 2008. The ‘Fractionable Autism Triad’: A Review of Evidence from Behavioural, Genetic, Cognitive and Neural Research. Neuropsychology Review. 18(4): 287–304.

Haraway, Donna. 1988. Situated Knowledges: The Science Question in Feminism and the Privilege of Partial Perspective. Feminist Studies. 14(3): 575–599.

Hare, R D. 2003. The Psychopathy Checklist – Revised, 2nd Edition. Toronto, ON: Multi-Health Systems, Inc.

Hayes, Jennie, Tamsin Ford, Hateem Rafeeque, and Ginny Russell. 2018. Clinical Practice Guidelines for Diagnosis of Autism Spectrum Disorder in Adults and Children in the UK: A Narrative Review. BMC Psychiatry. 18(1): 222.

Hedgecoe, Adam. 2004. The Politics of Personalised Medicine: Pharmacogenetics in the Clinic. New York: Cambridge University Press..

Izuma, Keise, Kenji Matsumoto, Colin F. Camerer, and Ralph Adolphs. 2011. Insensitivity to Social Reputation in Autism. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 108(42): 17302–17307.

Jenkins, Tania M., and Susan E. Short. 2017. Negotiating Intersex: A Case for Revising the Theory of Social Diagnosis. Social Science & Medicine (1982) 175: 91–98.

Jutel, Annemarie. 2011. Putting a Name to It: Diagnosis in Contemporary Society. JHU Press.

Jutel, Annemarie, and Sarah Nettleton. 2011. “Towards a Sociology of Diagnosis: Reflections and Opportunities.” Social Science & Medicine (1982) 73 (6): 793–800. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socscimed.2011.07.014..

Kapp, Steven K., Kristen Gillespie-Lynch, Lauren E. Sherman, and Ted Hutman. 2013. Deficit, Difference, or Both? Autism and Neurodiversity. Developmental Psychology. 49(1): 59–71.

Keehn, Brandon, Ralph-Axel Müller, and Jeanne Townsend. 2013. Atypical Attentional Networks and the Emergence of Autism. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 37(2): 164–183.

Kenny, Lorcan, Caroline Hattersley, Bonnie Molins, et al. 2015. Which Terms Should Be Used to Describe Autism? Perspectives from the UK Autism Community. Autism.

Kirchgessner, Megan A., Alice Z. Chuang, Saumil S. Patel, and Anne B. Sereno. 2015. Intact Reflexive but Deficient Voluntary Social Orienting in Autism Spectrum Disorder. Frontiers in Neuroscience 9. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4665260/.

Lawson, Wendy. 2008. Concepts of Normality: The Autistic and Typical Spectrum. Jessica Kingsley Publishers.

Lawson, Wendy. 2010 The Passionate Mind: How People with Autism Learn. Jessica Kingsley Publishers.

Latimer, Joanna. 2013. The Gene, the Clinic, and the Family: Diagnosing Dysmorphology, Reviving Medical Dominance. Routledge.

Lord, C., M. Rutter, and A. Couteur. 1994. Autism Diagnostic Interview-Revised: A Revised Version of a Diagnostic Interview for Caregivers of Individuals with Possible Pervasive Developmental Disorders. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders. 24(5): 659–685.

Lord, Catherine, Eva Petkova, Vanessa Hus, et al. 2012. A Multisite Study of the Clinical Diagnosis of Different Autism Spectrum Disorders. Archives of General Psychiatry 69(3): 306–313.

Maynard, Douglas W., and Jason J. Turowetz. 2017. Doing Testing: How Concrete Competence Can Facilitate or Inhibit Performances of Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder. Qualitative Sociology 40(4): 467–491.

Miller, Audrey K., Katrina A. Rufino, Marcus T. Boccaccini, Rebecca L. Jackson, and Daniel C. Murrie. 2011. On Individual Differences in Person Perception: Raters’ Personality Traits Relate to Their Psychopathy Checklist-Revised Scoring Tendencies. Assessment 18(2): 253–260.

Milton, Damian E. M. 2012. On the Ontological Status of Autism: The ‘Double Empathy Problem.’ Disability & Society 27(6): 883–887.

Milton, Damian E. M. 2014. Autistic Expertise: A Critical Reflection on the Production of Knowledge in Autism Studies. Autism 18(7): 794–802.

Mostofsky, Stewart H., and Joshua B. Ewen. 2011. Altered Connectivity and Action Model Formation in Autism Is Autism. The Neuroscientist 17(4): 437–448.

Mottron, Laurent. 2017. Should We Change Targets and Methods of Early Intervention in Autism, in Favor of a Strengths-Based Education? European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 26(7): 815–825.

Mottron, Laurent, Michelle Dawson, Isabelle Soulières, Benedicte Hubert, and Jake Burack.

Enhanced Perceptual Functioning in Autism: An Update, and Eight Principles of Autistic Perception. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 36(1): 27–43.

Müller, Ralph-Axel, and David G. Amaral. 2017. Editorial: Time to Give up on Autism Spectrum Disorder? Autism Research 10(1): 10–14.

Murray, Dinah, Mike Lesser, and Wendy Lawson. 2005. Attention, Monotropism and the Diagnostic Criteria for Autism. Autism 9(2): 139–156.

Nentjes, Lieke, David P. Bernstein, Arnoud Arntz, Mariëtte E. Slaats, and Tina Hannemann. 2015. Theory of Mind, Social Desirability, and Unlikely Symptom Reporting in Offenders With and Without Psychopathy. Journal of Nervous & Mental Disease 203(8): 596–603.

Norbury, Courtenay Frazier, Helen Griffiths, and Kate Nation. 2010. Sound before Meaning: Word Learning in Autistic Disorders. Neuropsychologia 48(14): 4012–4019.

Ortega, Francisco. 2009. The Cerebral Subject and the Challenge of Neurodiversity. BioSocieties 4(04): 425–445.

Parma, Valentina, Maria Bulgheroni, Roberto Tirindelli, and Umberto Castiello. 2013. Body Odors Promote Automatic Imitation in Autism. Biological Psychiatry 74(3). Oxytocin and Autism: 220–226.

Pellicano, Elizabeth. 2012. Do Autistic Symptoms Persist Across Time? Evidence of Substantial Change in Symptomatology Over a 3-Year Period in Cognitively Able Children With Autism. American Journal on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities 117(2): 156–166.

Piven, Joseph, Jennifer Harper, Pat Palmer, and Stephan Arndt. 1996. Course of Behavioral Change in Autism: A Retrospective Study of High-IQ Adolescents and Adults. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 35(4): 523–529.

Prainsack, Barbara, and Alena Buyx. 2011. Solidarity: Reflections on an Emerging Concept in Bioethics. Nuffield Council on Bioethics.

Robinson, Emily V., and Richard Rogers. 2015. Empathy Faking in Psychopathic Offenders: The Vulnerability of Empathy Measures. Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment 37(4): 545–552.

Rogers, Sally J. 2009. What Are Infant Siblings Teaching Us about Autism in Infancy? Autism Research. 2(3): 125–137.

Rose, Nikolas. 2013. What Is Diagnosis For? Royal College of Psychiatry: Conference on DSM-5 and the Future of Diagnosis.

Rosenhan, D L. 1973. “On Being Sane in Insane Places.” Science (New York, N.Y.) 179 (70): 250–58. https://doi.org/4683124..

Sacrey, Lori-Ann R., Vickie L. Armstrong, Susan E. Bryson, and Lonnie Zwaigenbaum. 2014. Impairments to Visual Disengagement in Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Review of Experimental Studies from Infancy to Adulthood. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 47: 559–577.

Sacrey, Lori-Ann R., Jeffrey A. Bennett, and Lonnie Zwaigenbaum. 2015. Early Infant Development and Intervention for Autism Spectrum Disorder. Journal of Child Neurology 30(14): 1921–1929.

Sasson, Noah J., Daniel J. Faso, Jack Nugent, et al. 2017. Neurotypical Peers Are Less Willing to Interact with Those with Autism Based on Thin Slice Judgments. Scientific Reports 7. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5286449/.

Satel, Sally, and Scott O. Lilienfeld. 2013. Brainwashed: The Seductive Appeal of Mindless Neuroscience. New York: Basic Civitas Books.

Seltzer, Marsha Mailick, Marty Wyngaarden Krauss, Paul T. Shattuck, et al. 2003. The Symptoms of Autism Spectrum Disorders in Adolescence and Adulthood. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 33(6): 565–581.

Sheppard, Elizabeth, Dhanya Pillai, Genevieve Tze-Lynn Wong, Danielle Ropar, and Peter Mitchell. 2016. How Easy Is It to Read the Minds of People with Autism Spectrum Disorder? Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 46(4): 1247–1254.

Sinclair, Jim. 2012. Don’t Mourn for Us. Autonomy, the Critical Journal of Interdisciplinary Autism Studies 1(1). http://www.larry-arnold.net/Autonomy/index.php/autonomy/article/view/AR1, accessed July 17, 2017.

Sizoo, Bram B, EH Horwitz, JP Teunisse, et al. 2015. Predictive Validity of Self-Report Questionnaires in the Assessment of Autism Spectrum Disorders in Adults. Autism 19(7): 842–849.

Soke, Gnakub Norbert, Amy Philofsky, Carolyn Diguiseppi, et al. 2011. Longitudinal Changes in Scores on the Autism Diagnostic Interview—Revised (ADI-R) in Pre-School Children with Autism: Implications for Diagnostic Classification and Symptom Stability. Autism 15(5): 545–562.

Solomon, O. 2011. Rethinking Baby Talk. In: The Handbook of Language Socialization Pp. 121–149. Chichester, UK: Willey-Blackwell.

Sowden, Sophie, Svenja Koehne, Caroline Catmur, Isabel Dziobek, and Geoffrey Bird. 2016. Intact Automatic Imitation and Typical Spatial Compatibility in Autism Spectrum Disorder: Challenging the Broken Mirror Theory. Autism Research 9(2): 292–300.

Spengler, Stephanie, Geoffrey Bird, and Marcel Brass. 2010. Hyperimitation of Actions Is Related to Reduced Understanding of Others’ Minds in Autism Spectrum Conditions. Biological Psychiatry. 68(12). Cortical Development and Cognitive Function: 1148–1155.

Starr, Sandy. 2009. Conversations with the Author (Personal Communication).

Stratis, Elizabeth A., and Luc Lecavalier. 2015. Informant Agreement for Youth with Autism Spectrum Disorder or Intellectual Disability: A Meta-Analysis. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 45(4): 1026–1041.

Swedo, Susan E., Gillian Baird, Edwin H. Cook, et al. 2012. Commentary from the DSM-5 Workgroup on Neurodevelopmental Disorders. Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 51(4): 347–349.

Timimi, Sami, Niel Gardner, and Bain McCabe. 2011. The Myth of Autism. UK: Palgrave-MacMillan.

Tottenham, Nim, Margaret E. Hertzig, Kristen Gillespie-Lynch, et al. 2014 . Elevated Amygdala Response to Faces and Gaze Aversion in Autism Spectrum Disorder. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience 9(1): 106–117.

Turowetz, Jason. 2015. The Interactional Production of a Clinical Fact in a Case of Autism. Qualitative Sociology 38(1): 57–78.

Verhoeff, Berend. 2012. What Is This Thing Called Autism? A Critical Analysis of the Tenacious Search for Autism’s Essence. BioSocieties 7(4): 410–432.

Walsh, Pat. 2010. Asperger Syndrome and the Supposed Obligation Not to Bring Disabled Lives into the World. Journal of Medical Ethics: jme.2010.036459.

Weisberg, Jill, Shawn C. Milleville, Lauren Kenworthy, et al. 2012. Social Perception in Autism Spectrum Disorders: Impaired Category Selectivity for Dynamic but Not Static Images in Ventral Temporal Cortex. Cerebral Cortex 24(1): 37–48.

White, Susan W., Brenna B. Maddox, and Robin K. Panneton. 2015. Fear of Negative Evaluation Influences Eye Gaze in Adolescents with Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Pilot Study. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 45(11): 3446–3457.

Wing, Lorna, Susan R. Leekam, Sarah J. Libby, Judith Gould, and Michael Larcombe. 2002. The Diagnostic Interview for Social and Communication Disorders: Background, Inter-Rater Reliability and Clinical Use. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 43(3): 307–325.

Wirth, James H., Donald F. Sacco, Kurt Hugenberg, and Kipling D. Williams. 2010. Eye Gaze as Relational Evaluation: Averted Eye Gaze Leads to Feelings of Ostracism and Relational Devaluation. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 36(7): 869–882.

Wittemeyer, K., A. English, G. Jones, L. Lyn-Cook, and D. Milton. 2012. Schools Autism Competency Framework. London: AET.

Zander, Eric, Charlotte Willfors, Steve Berggren, et al. 2016. The Objectivity of the Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule (ADOS) in Naturalistic Clinical Settings. European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 25(7): 769–780.


Full Text: HTML DOC

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.